Quote sally cinnamon="sally cinnamon"I'm surprised how highly some people rate Catalans. To me they look like a side that will come somewhere from 5th-8th.
They have become similar to the London Broncos in the old days, when they would fluctuate from bottom of the league one year to mid table the next.
A decent team yes who will get some good results in France but this isn't the first post I've seen here recently saying they could be challengers for the League Leaders Shield....does that squad honestly look better than us, Wigan or Saints?
How many of their players would you take ahead of ours? Which areas of the team is it stronger?'"
I don't think they'll win the league leaders, not because of squad strength but I don't think it's possible with the travel that they do, if they ever did it, I think it would be a sensational achievement.
Ref squad strength, Is it as strong as 'the big sides' ? I'm not sure, in some areas I think it could be and in others not so much, I think they lack some genuine strike threat in their three quarters excluding Greenshields and say Blanch at a push. I also have a lot of time for Jean-Phillipe Baile at centre, though I think he has some rough edges, but also tonnes of ability.
I think that young hooker, Pellisier (sic), he looks a talent, he could be a real one to watch from the bench in an Isaac Luke role.
Their pack is as good as anything in SL, just ill disciplined at times, Louis Anderson & Oliver Elima in the backrow, there's no more physical partnership than that but they'll gift away too many daft pens, throw in Fakir, Casty, Ferriol and a bit of Menzies guile then Henderson scooting here, there & everywhere and I like their pack immensely but they have a combustable element they need to control.
Bosc, Pryce & Dureau are as good as any halfback combo's kicking around in SL for me.
I'll probably get hammered for this, but I think I'd take their pack over Leeds or Wigan definately. It's whether from there they have the ability to put points on the board, maybe adding Pryce will help, but I'd like to have seen a little more added to the backline. Dare I say it, I think they're missing a King or a Carmont, somebody like that.